whats your favorite pie

[renovation]

APPLE is mine

[thresher]

Buttermilk. Yummy. Good thread, can't wait to hear what other pies get added. Mmmmmm.
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5204275

[Kim]

Huckleberry

[Markel]

I would have to go with some kind of (or mix of) berry.

[johnnymk]

Pecan

[MrGreg]

Peanut Butter
(from the airport in Sitka, AK)

[ShawnLee]

Peanut Butter
(from the airport in Sitka, AK)
That's a pretty specific pie right there. If EVER I'm in Sitka, AK, I'm now obligated to go to their airport to try the peanut butter pie.

Me? I'm a fan of all major pies. If it's well done, it's a good pie for me.

[Prngr44]

Pecan

:agree:

[DarkFury]

Apple, Sweet Potato, Pecan, Key Lime, and Cheesecake.

Of course there is "poontang pie" as well.. but we ain't goin' there in this dicussion. :naughty: ;)

[johnnymk]

Apple, Sweet Potato, Pecan, Key Lime, and Cheesecake.

Of course there is "poontang pie" as well.. but we ain't goin' there in this dicussion. :naughty: ;)

Is that the same recipe for carpet muncher pie?

[chrissy]

Lemon

[tweeteresa]

French apple/apple strudel

FYI, Marie Callendar's is having their $5.99 pie sale right now. Nothing fantastic but they're not bad.

[Nija]

Cheesecake, then pumpkin.

[cheapie]

my wife makes a great pumpkin cheesecake pie.

sweet potato, cottage, rhubarb, real cherry....

[zenbooty]

Steak and Onion, cherry, chocolate cream.

[uncledaddy]

Banana Cream and Coconut. :lick:

[DarkFury]

Banana Cream and Coconut. :lick:
Gilligan... is that you? :D

[brainsmile]

Cherry is great but usually too sweet. Chocolate. mmmmmmmm

[Markel]

I would say that cheesecake has no place in a discussion about pie. It's a completely different species. (I would take a slice of a good cheesecake over any kind of pie.)

[renovation]

I would say that cheesecake has no place in a discussion about pie. It's a completely different species. (I would take a slice of a good cheesecake over any kind of pie.)

:stupid:

[DarkFury]

I would say that cheesecake has no place in a discussion about pie. It's a completely different species. (I would take a slice of a good cheesecake over any kind of pie.)
Is cheesecake really a cake... or is it a pie?

Cheescake is prepared just like most pies...and poured into a graham cracker crust just like a pie. Yes, it has "cake" in it's name, but honestly... isn't it really a "pie"?

[thresher]

sweet potato, cottage, rhubarb, real cherry....
Cheapie, you truly are my brother from another mother! Have you ever tried buttermilk pie since you obvious like such great southern favorites?

[Sirrich3]

Chocolate Satin from Marie Callendars!

[ShawnLee]

Is cheesecake really a cake... or is it a pie?

Cheescake is prepared just like most pies...and poured into a graham cracker crust just like a pie. Yes, it has "cake" in it's name, but honestly... isn't it really a "pie"?
:stupid:
Let's say this cream made of cheese and various other delicious and lethal edibles wasn't made of cheese, but rather pumpkin. It wouldn't then be called pumpkincake, nay - I agree with DF - it's a pie by another name.

But, eh. What's in a name? That which we call a rose by any other name would smell just as sweet.

[Markel]

There's cake. There's pie. And there's cheesecake. All quite distinct. Just because a cheesecake is shaped and cut like a pie doesn't make it a pie, any more than it makes meatloaf a piece of bread.

[Nija]

Cheesecake > Pie > Cake

[guiseppewv]

Pie > 99% of all desserts

Blueberry is my favorite! One of my grandmothers used to make a killer ricotta pie and the other made a killer rhubarb pie. :lick:

[DarkFury]

There's cake. There's pie. And there's cheesecake. All quite distinct. Just because a cheesecake is shaped and cut like a pie doesn't make it a pie, any more than it makes meatloaf a piece of bread.
If you say so.... :shrug:

Still, cheesecake filling is so similar to other pie fillings that honestly, I don't make the connection to your analogy.

Bread does not equal meat, and we are not basing the connection on just the shape alone.

Most cakes rise when you cook them, most pies don't. Cheesecake doesn't rise either. Most cakes are not poured into a "shell", however most pies are. It still more closely resembles a pie and the "pie family".

But whatever... just enjoy the cheesecake is what I say (make mine with strawberry topping please. :D )

[Markel]

Cheesecake > Pie > Cake
:stupid: Well stated! :lick: