PDA

View Full Version : Our Litigious Society



Joshua
10-31-2003, 06:52 AM
* From News of the weird.

* Former Ball State University student Andrew Bourne, 23, and his
parents filed a lawsuit in September against the school and the
manufacturer of its aluminum football goal posts. Bourne suffered
a broken leg and vertebrae when, during a raucous end-zone
celebration after a 2001 victory over the University of Toledo,
students pulled down the goal posts, hitting Bourne. [USA Today,
9-30-03]

(N) John Clayton III was awarded $1.5 million by a jury in
Greensboro, N.C., in September based on injuries he suffered as a
passenger in a car whose driver had to slam on the brakes to avoid
a collision. The car Clayton was a passenger in was a police car; he
was being brought to the station on an outstanding arrest warrant
when the officer-driver hit the brakes. Clayton claimed the sudden
stop caused him "back problems." [Charlotte Observer-AP, 9-28-
03]

* Kevin Presland was awarded about the equivalent of US$150,000
by a judge in Sydney, Australia, in August because the Hunter Area
Health Service psychiatric hospital released him too soon in 1995,
after which he killed his brother's fiancee. This was not a lawsuit
by the victim's family against the hospital; this was a direct payout
to Presland, whose injury was that he was made to suffer temporary
prison conditions after his arrest (he was acquitted because of his
psychosis), whereas if he had never been released, he would have
experienced only psychiatric-hospital conditions. [The Australian,
8-20-03]

* Former Kansas City Royals coach Tom Gamboa filed a lawsuit in
September against a fan who attacked him during a September
2002 baseball game in Chicago, and also against the ballpark's
(U.S. Cellular Field's) security firm and its concessionaire.
(However, several days after the initial attack, Gamboa had told the
Associated Press, "The fault is with the two people [the fan and his
minor son] who did it. I'm not one who looks to [spread] blame.
It's nobody's fault but the two idiots who did it.") [San Francisco
Chronicle-AP, 9-19-03; Sports Illustrated-AP, 9-24-02]

bachviet
10-31-2003, 11:03 AM
The first 3 lawsuits are just ridiculous. :eek:

RoniMan
10-31-2003, 11:07 AM
Former Ball State University student Andrew Bourne, 23, and his
parents filed a lawsuit in September against the school and the
manufacturer of its aluminum football goal posts. Bourne suffered
a broken leg and vertebrae when, during a raucous end-zone
celebration after a 2001 victory over the University of Toledo,
students pulled down the goal posts, hitting Bourne.

wonderful...after this lawsuit, all school will have to replace their aluminum posts with nerf material.:rolleyes:

welfareloser
10-31-2003, 11:22 AM
they're not all ridiculous. it makes a cute little soundbyte to make fun of someone who got arrested suing the cop, but the police officer was driving like crap ("stopping suddenly to avoid a collision" translates as "driving too fast and almost rear-ended someone") and you don't get a seatbelt when riding in the back of a cop car, even though you should.

as for the psychotic guy, if it was obvious he shouldn't have been released - and it sounds like it was - he deserves a payout. he has to live with the fact that he murdered someone, and it could have been avoided if the administration had done their job.

pulling down endzone goal posts... well... if they were improperly installed, someone should get in trouble. otherwise, load o' crap.

and the last one is only bad because of the guy's turnaround on who's fault it might have been.

InfiniteNothing
10-31-2003, 01:43 PM
Unless the cop had super duper breaks I can't imagine stopping so fast that someone gets injured.

cheapie
10-31-2003, 02:23 PM
Originally posted by InfiniteNothing
Unless the cop had super duper breaks I can't imagine stopping so fast that someone gets injured.



this is the ONLY one i agree with WL on. lets say you've just been stuck in the back of a squad car on those plastic seats they sometimes have w/handcuffs. the driver hits the brakes and you're hands are stuck behind your back. how in the world are you going to stop your self w/something other than your head?

InfiniteNothing
10-31-2003, 02:39 PM
Somehow I had assumed he had a seat belt on. I guess I haven't been arrested all that often. But he was complaining about his back, not his broken nose.

welfareloser
10-31-2003, 03:18 PM
it'd hurt your back, even if he slammed the brakes from 30 mph. trust me.